← Back to the game

Compare

Schotten Totten vs Lost Cities: Which Game to Buy?

Two small boxes, one designer, the same year, nearly the same price. One is a fight over a border; the other is a race against your own budget. Here is how they differ, and which one to buy.

By · Updated · 6 min

Two classics from the same year

Buy Schotten Totten if you want a head-on duel of deduction where every card you play is aimed at your opponent; buy Lost Cities if you would rather manage your own risk at a calmer table. Both are two-player Knizia card games that sell for under $20, so the choice is about how you like to play, not the price.

Reiner Knizia published both in 1999, and both are two-player card games built on coloured suits and numbered cards. That is where the family resemblance ends.

Schotten Totten is a head-on contest. Nine border stones lie between you, and each one is won by building a better three-card formation than your opponent on your side of it. Every card you play is aimed at them.

Lost Cities (Kosmos) is a quieter game of investment. You each build your own expeditions in front of you, and the question is less "can I beat them here?" than "is this expedition worth starting at all?". The tension comes from your own hand and the shrinking deck.

Side by side

AspectSchotten TottenLost Cities
Designer / yearReiner Knizia, 1999Reiner Knizia, 1999 (Kosmos)
Cards54 (values 1–9, 6 colours)60 (values 2–10 plus 3 wager cards per colour, 5 colours)
Cards in hand68
On your turnplay a card at a stone, then drawplay or discard a card, then draw from the deck or a discard pile
Where cards goyour side of 9 shared stonesyour own expeditions, one per colour
Card orderanystrictly ascending within an expedition
Scoringwin 5 stones, or 3 adjacentpoints: card total minus 20, multiplied by wagers
Match lengthone gamethree rounds, scores added
Interactiondirect: every stone is contestedindirect: discards your opponent can take

Sources: the Lost Cities rulebook on RulesPal (cards, hand, card order, scoring, end of a round, three rounds) and the Schotten Totten rulebook on RulesPal.

How they feel at the table

  • Schotten Totten is a tug of war. You read your opponent's formations, count the cards still out, and choose the moment to claim a stone, which you may do early only when you can prove they cannot beat you (the claim rule, explained). Every decision is relative to what they hold.
  • Lost Cities is push-your-luck. Each expedition you open costs 20 points before it earns any, wager cards double, triple or quadruple the result (losses included), and an expedition of eight or more cards earns a 20-point bonus. You mostly fight the clock: the round ends the moment the last deck card is drawn.
  • Information. Both games hide your hand. In Schotten Totten you deduce from the board which formations are still possible (the exact odds); in Lost Cities you watch the discard piles, because anything you throw away your opponent may pick up.
  • Pace. Schotten Totten is decided in one tense game. Lost Cities is meant to be played over three rounds, so a bad round can be recovered.
  • The deck as a clock. In both games the draw pile sets the pace. A Lost Cities round ends with the last card drawn; in 400 seeded games of this site's AI playing Schotten Totten against itself (base game, last counted on 15 October 2026), 399 ran the deck out before the duel was decided, after a median of 50 cards played.

Which one should you buy?

Both boxes are small and cheap. This is what the publishers and US shops showed on 22 October 2026:

In the shopSchotten TottenLost Cities
EditionIELLO, 2016Thames & Kosmos, with a sixth expedition as an option
Players2 only2 only
Age on the box8 and up10 and up
Play time on the box20 minutes30 minutes
Price, new (US)$16.49 at Noble Knight Games, list price $17.99, in stock$18.49 at Noble Knight Games, list price $19.95, in stock

Sources, read on 22 October 2026: IELLO's Schotten Totten page and its Noble Knight listing; the Lost Cities Noble Knight listing for age, time and price, and Asmodee Canada's listing, which says "This version contains the 6th Expedition expansion". The rules on this page are those of the five-expedition game. Whether Schotten Totten is worth its price on its own is the subject of our Schotten Totten review.

  • Buy Schotten Totten if you want direct confrontation and deduction: bluffing with weak cards, racing for the same stone, proving a claim. It suits players who like chess-like duels.
  • Buy Lost Cities if you prefer building your own plans, measured risk and a calmer table. It is a classic couples' game for a reason: you play side by side more than against each other.
  • Both, if you want two very different Knizia duels on the shelf. They take the same space and rarely compete for the same evening.
  • Neither, quite? Our list of games like Schotten Totten ranks the closest duels, and Schotten Totten vs Air, Land and Sea compares the shortest of them.

Want to try Schotten Totten first? Play it free in your browser against the AI or a friend. New to it? Start with the rules in five minutes. Lost Cities can be played on Board Game Arena.

The difference in five lines

  • Both are Reiner Knizia two-player card games from 1999, with coloured suits and numbered cards.
  • Schotten Totten is a direct fight over nine shared stones; Lost Cities is about building your own five expeditions.
  • Schotten Totten is won by stones (5 total or 3 adjacent); Lost Cities by points over three rounds.
  • Lost Cities is push-your-luck: every expedition starts at minus 20, and wager cards multiply wins and losses.
  • Buy Schotten Totten for confrontation and deduction, Lost Cities for calmer planning and risk; both cost under $20 in the US.

Frequently asked questions

Are Schotten Totten and Lost Cities by the same designer?

Yes. Both were designed by Reiner Knizia and published in 1999. They share the idea of coloured suits and numbered cards, but they play very differently.

Which is easier to learn?

Both can be taught in a few minutes. Schotten Totten's only subtle rule is claiming a stone early; Lost Cities' only subtle part is its scoring, where each expedition starts at minus 20 and wager cards multiply the result.

Which is more interactive?

Schotten Totten. Every stone is contested directly by both players. In Lost Cities you each build your own expeditions, and the main interaction is through discards your opponent can pick up.

Is Lost Cities a good game for couples?

Yes, it is often recommended as one, because it is calm and you mostly race your own plans. Schotten Totten is better if you both enjoy a more confrontational duel.

Which one costs less?

They cost about the same. On 22 October 2026 Noble Knight Games sold Schotten Totten new for $16.49 and the current Thames & Kosmos edition of Lost Cities for $18.49. Prices move, so check before you buy.

Which one should I buy for a child?

Either works with help, but Schotten Totten is boxed for ages 8 and up and Lost Cities for 10 and up. Lost Cities asks for more arithmetic at the end of each round; Schotten Totten asks only which side of a stone is stronger.

Can I play them online?

Schotten Totten can be played free on this site against the AI or a friend. Lost Cities can be played on Board Game Arena.

Lost Cities details are drawn from its published rules and public references; Schotten Totten details from its official rules. Prices, ages and play times were read on the linked publisher and shop pages on 22 October 2026. Both games are designed by Reiner Knizia. This site is an unofficial fan project and plays Schotten Totten only.