← Back to the game

Rules

Schotten Totten Versions: The Editions Since 1999

Found an old box, or torn between two listings? Every version has the same deck, and one rule has moved since 1999. Here is what changes from box to box, which box is in English, and which ones come with the Tactic cards.

By · Updated · 6 min

Same deck in every box, one rule moved

Every Schotten Totten version is played with the same deck. The first edition, the 1999 original from Germany, contains "54 playing cards in 6 colours, 9 cards depicting the victory stones and rules", according to its BoardGameGeek page. IELLO's English rulebook lists the same 54 Clan cards, numbered 1 to 9 in 6 colours, with 9 stones printed as tiles. The deck has not changed since 1999, so the Schotten Totten rules you read in English today play on a 1999 box without changing a card.

One rule has moved since then: when you claim a stone. The English rules of 1999 have you claim at the start of your turn, before you play a card. IELLO's rulebook lets you claim after you play, before you draw, and keeps the old timing as an optional variant. Both are quoted in the section on old boxes below.

Three things do change from one box to the next, and none of them changes the 54-card deck:

  • The artwork. Bärbel Skarabela and Dorien Boekhorst drew the early boxes; Djib (Jean-Baptiste Reynaud) drew IELLO's in 2016. At least one foreign edition, the Polish "Spór o Bór", has its own art.
  • The stones. Cards in the first edition, tiles in the IELLO box.
  • The Tactic cards. This optional set of 10 cards came later: some boxes have it, others do not.

Which versions are in English?

One box: IELLO's. BoardGameGeek calls every published box a version, and each reprint gets a row of its own. On 18 November 2026 we counted the rows of its version list for the game: 29 versions in 14 languages. Four of them are in English, and all four are IELLO printings, dated 2016, 2017, 2020 and 2021. The last three carry the product code 51303, and the 2017 row adds the barcode 3760175513039, a number you can type into a shop's search field to find the English box. None of the other 25 versions is in English. IELLO's French box is a separate product, code 51302 on its BoardGameGeek page, so check the code when a European shop lists both.

In the United States, Blue Orange Games lists the box on its own site as item #51303, with the contents the rulebook prints: "54 Clan Cards, 10 Tactic Cards, 9 Stone Tiles, 2 Player Aids, 1 Rulebook". The item number is the code BoardGameGeek gives IELLO's English box, and the contents match, so this is IELLO's box with a new distributor, not a new edition. IELLO announced the partnership on 27 July 2025, "to continue the distribution of IELLO's catalog in the United States" (IELLO press release).

Before 2016, the version list has no English-language Schotten Totten box at all. The rules were in English as early as 1999, though: Reiner Knizia and Kevin Jacklin translated those of the 1999 German box, and that translation is the one quoted further down. GMT Games then published Battle Line, Knizia's redesign of the game, in 2000; it has its own section below.

The editions table

The table puts the English box first, then the two German boxes of 1999, then the later editions in date order. Each row links its BoardGameGeek version page. "Not stated" means the page does not say, not that the box lacks it.

YearPublisherLanguageArtworkTactic cardsSource
2016, reprinted 2017, 2020, 2021IELLO (the 2016 row also names ASS Altenburger Spielkarten)EnglishDjib (Jean-Baptiste Reynaud)yes, 10BGG 294385, 667087, 585533, 702230, rulebook
1999ASS Altenburger SpielkartenGermanBärbel Skarabela, Dorien BoekhorstnoBGG 33659
1999Schmidt SpieleGermanDorien Boekhorstnot statedBGG 47619
2004Pro LudoGermanBärbel Skarabela, Dorien Boekhorstnot statedBGG 28217
2004PS-GamesDutchBärbel Skarabela, Dorien Boekhorstnot statedBGG 20888
2004PS-Games and UbikFrenchBärbel Skarabela, Dorien Boekhorstyes, Battle Line'sBGG 26310
2007PS-Games and Edge EntertainmentFrenchBärbel Skarabela, Dorien BoekhorstyesBGG 118581
2013Edge EntertainmentFrench and Spanishnot statednot statedBGG 241108
2016IELLOFrenchDjib (Jean-Baptiste Reynaud)yes, 10BGG 293016, rulebook
2018Redbox EditoraPortugueseBärbel Skarabela, Dorien Boekhorst, Jean-Baptiste Reynaudnot statedBGG 465709
2021Muduko, as "Spór o Bór"PolishPiotr Sokołowskinot statedBGG 582703
2024Pegasus SpieleGermannot statednot statedBGG 720005

Sources: BoardGameGeek version pages, read on 18 November 2026; IELLO's English and French rulebooks for the contents of the IELLO box.

The German line runs from ASS Altenburger Spielkarten and Schmidt Spiele in 1999 to Pro Ludo in 2004 and Pegasus Spiele in 2024. If you are after the original art with the Tactic cards, the two French boxes look almost alike: according to their pages, the 2004 box carries Ubik's logo on its bottom and two sides, and the 2007 box carries Edge's in its place. BoardGameGeek also lists versions in Czech, Greek, Hungarian, Italian, Korean, Spanish, Ukrainian and, since 2026, Serbian.

The Tactic cards, the one real difference in the box

If you check one thing on an old box, check for the 10 Tactic cards. They come from Battle Line (2000), and BoardGameGeek's page for the game says that "the 2004 Edition of Schottentotten has these 'tactics' cards too". The page of the 2004 French edition is just as explicit: "The French edition includes the tactics cards of Battle Line." Its 2007 successor says the same. The 1999 German first edition, by contrast, lists its contents with no Tactic card at all.

The base game does not need them. It is complete on its own, and IELLO's rulebook teaches it first, then presents the Tactic cards as a variant at the end of the book, on pages 11 to 15: Elite Troops (two Jokers among them), Combat Modes that change how a single stone is won, and Ruses that work on the deck or on cards already played. To see what each card does before you hunt for a box that has them, read our guide to the Schotten Totten tactics cards.

Playing an old box with the English rules

You need English rules, not an English box. The deck and the stones are the same from the 1999 box to the IELLO one, so our guide to how to play Schotten Totten works as well with a 1999 German box or a 2004 French one as with the IELLO box.

The one rule to agree on is when you claim a stone. We have not read the German rule sheet of 1999, but we have read its English translation by Reiner Knizia and Kevin Jacklin, version 1.0 of 20 February 1999, written for the ASS box with the code 75006. It says: "On your turn, and before you play your card, you may claim one or more boundary-stones." IELLO's rulebook moves the claim to "After playing a card on a Stone and before drawing" (page 7) and keeps the old timing as its Schotten Totten Expert variant: "you can only claim a Stone at the beginning of your turn, before playing a card" (page 16). So if an old sheet tells you to claim at the start of your turn, you are playing the 1999 rule, and nothing stops you keeping it.

On the other rules of play we compared, the 1999 translation and IELLO's rulebook agree: six cards in hand, at most three cards on each side of a stone, the same five formations in the same order, the same tie-break, and the same two ways to win, three adjacent stones or five anywhere.

To check that a second-hand box is complete, count the cards:

  • 54 Clan cards, numbered 1 to 9 in 6 colours, for the base game;
  • 9 stones, as cards in the early editions or as tiles in the IELLO box;
  • 10 Tactic cards, if your box came with them;
  • in the IELLO box, 2 Player Aids that rank the formations as well (if they are missing, print our own player aid).

Battle Line, Battle Line: Medieval and Schotten Totten 2 are not editions

Three other boxes come up next to Schotten Totten in searches, and none of them is an edition of it.

Battle Line (GMT Games, 2000) is Reiner Knizia's own redesign of the game, with an ancient theme. The idea is the same, but the deck is not: its rulebook lists 60 cards valued 1 to 10 in 6 colours, with a hand of 7 and the tactics built in. Its cards carry other art, so one of them will not pass for a missing card in a Schotten Totten box. A whole Battle Line deck with its six 10s set aside, though, leaves 54 cards numbered 1 to 9 in 6 colours: the Schotten Totten deck in all but the art. Every rule that differs is in our comparison of Schotten Totten vs Battle Line.

Battle Line: Medieval (GMT Games) re-themes Battle Line, so it keeps Battle Line's deck: new art and a new setting on the same game. GMT describes "60 beautiful new cards by illustrator Roland MacDonald, as well as 10 full-color tactics 'wildcards'" on its product page. BoardGameGeek lists it as a reimplementation of both Battle Line and Schotten Totten and dates it 2017; GMT files its second printing under its 2019 releases.

Schotten Totten 2 (IELLO, 2020) keeps the card duel and turns it into a siege: one player attacks a wall, the other defends it, with 60 cards valued 0 to 11 in 5 colours, as its English rulebook lists them. It is a sequel, not a new edition. If "the original" means the first game as opposed to the sequel, it is the 1999 design that every box in the table contains. If you are choosing between the two, read Schotten Totten 1 or 2.

Which box to look for

If you wantLook forWhat you get
to play in English, newIELLO's box, code 51303English rules, the base game and the 10 Tactic cards, stones as tiles
the original art with the Tactic cardsthe French edition of 2004 (PS-Games and Ubik) or 2007 (PS-Games and Edge)the same game, Tactic cards included according to their BoardGameGeek pages; rules in French
the first edition, for a collectionASS Altenburger Spielkarten, 1999, code 75006the original German box, with no Tactic cards in its contents list
a bigger deck and a hand of 7Battle Line (GMT Games)Knizia's redesign, not an edition
a siege with two different rolesSchotten Totten 2 (IELLO)a sequel, not an edition

Whatever the box, the game stays the same: nine stones to fight over and the same deck, with one claim timing to agree on before you start. Before you buy, our Schotten Totten review says who the game suits and who it suits less. You can also try it first: the official licensed version is on Board Game Arena, and this site, an unofficial fan adaptation, plays it free against an AI or a friend.

Versions at a glance

  • The deck has not changed since 1999: the German first edition already had 54 Clan cards in 6 colours and 9 stones, like the IELLO box sold today.
  • One rule has moved: the 1999 English rules have you claim a stone at the start of your turn, before you play a card. IELLO's rulebook moves the claim to after you play and keeps the old timing as its Expert variant.
  • The one English-language box is IELLO's, first printed in 2016 and reprinted since under the code 51303; in the United States, Blue Orange Games distributes it.
  • The real difference in the box is the 10 Tactic cards: missing from the 1999 contents list, present in the French editions of 2004 and 2007 and in the IELLO box.
  • Battle Line is Knizia's redesign with a 60-card deck, Battle Line: Medieval re-themes it, and Schotten Totten 2 is a sequel. None of them is an edition.

Frequently asked questions

Are all Schotten Totten versions the same game?

Yes, with one rule that moved. The first edition, published in Germany in 1999, already has 54 Clan cards in 6 colours and 9 stones, the same deck as the box sold today. Its English rules of 1999 have you claim a stone at the start of your turn, before you play a card; IELLO's rulebook lets you claim after you play and keeps the old timing as its Expert variant. The artwork changed, the stones went from cards to tiles, and later boxes added an optional set of 10 Tactic cards.

Is there an English edition of Schotten Totten?

Yes, one. The English box is IELLO's, first printed in 2016 and reprinted since under the product code 51303. On 18 November 2026, the four English-language rows on BoardGameGeek's version list were all IELLO printings.

Can I play a 1999 German copy with the English rules?

Yes. The 1999 box has the same 54 Clan cards and 9 stones as the English box, so IELLO's English rules play on it unchanged. If you follow the 1999 rules instead, you claim at the start of your turn, which IELLO's rulebook calls the Expert variant. Only the Tactic variant needs more, the 10 Tactic cards, and the 1999 contents list does not include them.

Which Schotten Totten editions include the Tactic cards?

The current box, in English and in French, lists 10 Tactic cards in its contents. BoardGameGeek's pages say the French editions of 2004 (PS-Games and Ubik) and 2007 (PS-Games and Edge Entertainment) include them too. The 1999 German first edition lists none. For any other box, check the contents before you buy.

Is Battle Line the original version of Schotten Totten?

No. Schotten Totten came first, in 1999. Battle Line followed in 2000 from GMT Games, as Reiner Knizia's redesign with a deck of 60 cards valued 1 to 10, a hand of 7 and an ancient theme, and Battle Line: Medieval re-themes that redesign. Neither is an edition of Schotten Totten, although Schotten Totten later took its Tactic cards from Battle Line.

Is Schotten Totten 2 a new edition of Schotten Totten?

No. Schotten Totten 2, from 2020, is a sequel. It turns the duel into a siege in which one player attacks a wall and the other defends it, with 60 cards valued 0 to 11 in 5 colours. The first game is a separate box.

How do I recognise the 1999 first edition of Schotten Totten?

It is in German, published by ASS Altenburger Spielkarten under the product code 75006, with art by Bärbel Skarabela and Dorien Boekhorst, and its 9 stones are cards, not tiles. A Schmidt Spiele edition from the same year carries the same code.

An unofficial fan guide, not affiliated with IELLO. Years, publishers, artists and box contents come from BoardGameGeek's version pages, which its users maintain, read on 18 November 2026; the contents of the IELLO box come from its English rulebook and from Blue Orange Games' listing, and the 1999 rules from their English translation, all read the same day. If a listing and a box disagree, the box is right.